A college roommate of mine, still full of schadenfreude after seeing the Packers lose that exhausting 51-45 game on Sunday, told me about a poll a Madison radio station was running today. They listed three infamous Packers playoff losses- Sunday’s, the 2007 NFC Championship and the 2003 NFC Divisional game vs. the Eagles (the “4th and 26) game- and asked listeners which one was the most painful.
Well, I can’t let something like that go lightly…and it got me to thinking, “were those three really the worst three?” Here’s the reply I came up with:
Remember in Rounders when Mike McD says something like this- "Amazing as this sounds, poker players have a tough time remembering big hands they’ve won. But they can remember with incredible accuracy the outstanding tough beats of their career." It’s appropriate here because it’s so much easier to think of the tough losses the Packers have taken in the playoffs since they emerged from mediocrity back in the early 90s. While it’s better to have been in the playoffs and lost than to never have made it at all, it still sucks when your squad gets bounced. So, without any further adieu, here’s the top 5 crushing playoff defeats of my Packer fan career:
Honorable mention- 2004 Wild Card round, Vikings d. Packers @ Lambeau in the Moon Game. Yes, it sucks that the arch-rivals waltzed into Lambeau and knocked out the Pack and that Moss had to do his despicable, deplorable touchdown celebration (sorry, Joe Buck took control of my keyboard for a minute there). However, when I think of the 2004 season, I think of the Christmas Eve game two weeks prior where the Pack clinched the division by beating the Vikes. It’s memorable for me because I had to go to Christmas Eve Mass at 5pm that night (which doubled as the dedication of our remodeled church), which was right around when the game was getting over. Thankfully, I had Internet on my phone, and just as I was processing into the building, the last refresh showed that Ryan Longwell nailed the game-winning kick. Sing it with me…"Joy to the world, the kick was good." So when I think 2004, I think of that game, the game my dad minted “The Year B**tt F**re saved Christmas”. (Funny to think that F**re and Longwell were instrumental in that win…)
5th (tie)- 2009 loss to Cards, 1998 loss to 49ers. Both games ended on ridiculous last plays- the kick in the air pick this year, the TO catch in quadruple coverage in ’98. Deep down, though, the losses weren’t as horrible because in both years, there were buzzsaws waiting for them in Round 2. If you have to lose, better to lose a game like that rather than suffer a humiliating, demoralizing loss the next week (and yes, I think the Saints win big this weekend).
4th- 1997 Super Bowl loss to Broncos. Tough to rank this one as that painful when the Pack had won it all the year before. Still, every time NFL Films drags up that footage of Elway pinwheeling through the air for a first down ("WHAT A WARRIOR! There’s a guy who’s playing like he really wants that elusive championship!!") I want to puke. It’s like seeing those "Rebirth of a Legend" signs commemorating the remodeled Lambeau…and in that Rebirth of a Legend game, the Vikings hammered the Pack. Not a good association with those signs, nor that Elway video clip.
3rd- 2007 NFC Championship loss to the Giants. It was close between this one and the Super Bowl loss. It seemed like everything was breaking the Pack’s way…they get home field for the championship game, they had just annihilated the Seahawks in the Snow Bowl…and then cold-weather F**re napalms the season. No need to go into any more detail.
2nd- 2003 NFC Divisional Game vs. Eagles (the "4th and 26" game). The gap between 2nd and 3rd on this list is as big as the gap between Michael Strahan’s teeth. If things were going the Packers’ way in 2007, they were really going their way in 2003. Let’s not forget how they got into the playoffs that year (McCown…rolling out…fires it into the end zone…CAUGHT!!! TOUCHDOWN!!! NO!!!!!! THE CARDINALS HAVE KNOCKED THE VIKINGS OUT OF THE PLAYOFFS!!!), nor forget their wild-card game (Matt Hasselbeck’s infamous "we want the ball and we’re gonna score" call). I was convinced the Pack was going to the Super Bowl that year, and up until that freaking 4th and 26 play, they had been working over the Eagles all game. Then, if that wasn’t enough, F**re has to go and throw one of the most idiotic passes in playoff history to stick a fork in that season and a knife in my heart. Man, did that loss hurt.
Still, it doesn’t hold a candle to this one:
1st- 1995 NFC Championship Game loss to Cowboys. This was the perfect storm for a devastating loss- the Pack had never been that far in the playoffs during my life. They had just gone out to SF the week before and absolutely crushed the Niners (right up there with the Super Bowl win on my list of favorite Packers wins ever). The Cowboys had (briefly) passed the Vikings as my most despised team. Everyone in the universe was all about the Cowboys the week before the game (sound familiar?) but I was 100% convinced the Packers were winning that game. I think Erik Williams was convinced the Packers were going to win too, and since he couldn’t handle John Jurkovic on the line, he decided to destroy Jurko’s knee. After that, the game completely turned, the Pokes won 38-28 and then beat down Pittsburgh in the Super Bowl. 15 years later I’m still pissed about that. After driving back to SJU that night, I fired off a Ray Barbone-like e-mail featuring 43 f-bombs to a high school friend…man, I wish he would’ve kept that one.
I don’t think that game will ever be topped as far as painful losses go, mainly because a) since that point they did win a title, crossing off “seeing the Packers win a Super Bowl” on my Sports Bucket List, and b) I don’t think I’m capable of that level of anger anymore. It’s easy to get waaaaay too fired up about a football game when you’re 19 years old; you mellow out quite a bit by the time you’re pushing your mid-30s.
So, now that I’ve gone over 7 killer playoff losses in the last 15 years (wow…never thought of it like that before), I want your thoughts. What are the most killer losses your teams have put you through? I’m pretty sure I know what the Vikings fans will say, so if there are any fans of other teams that are reading this, comment away.